The slope stays 0.39, and the t-statistic grows from 1.6 to 2.3. The copies add no information, yet the slope now looks significant at 5%.
The regression fits \(y_i = a + b\,x_i + e_i\) to the \(n\) rows, where \(e_i\) is the residual of row \(i\). The least-squares slope divides the covariance of \(x\) and \(y\) by the variance of \(x\), both averages over the rows:
Copying every row doubles each sum and doubles \(n\), so both averages, and the slope, stay the same. The standard error of the slope is
where \(s^2\) estimates the variance of the errors, the sum of squared residuals divided by \(n - 2\), and the 2 counts the two estimated coefficients, \(a\) and \(b\). Copying every row doubles \(n \operatorname{Var}(x)\) and \(\sum_i e_i^2\), while \(n - 2\) grows to \(2n - 2\), so
The question gives three inputs:
| \(n\) |
number of rows before the copy |
30 |
| \(b\) |
slope |
0.39 |
| \(t\) |
t-statistic of the slope, \(b / \operatorname{SE}(b)\) |
1.6 |
The slope stays the same, so dividing it by (3) gives
The factor \(\sqrt{58/28} = 1.44\) is close to \(\sqrt{2}\) because \(n\) doubled. Formula (2) assumes \(n\) independent errors, but a copied row repeats the error of its original, so the 60 rows hold only 30 independent errors. The same overcount appears with overlapping returns, such as twelve-month returns measured every month, where Newey–West standard errors with 11 lags are the usual fix.
Three wrong answers are common:
| both stay the same |
misses that \(n\) in (2) doubles, so the standard error falls |
| t doubles |
lets the standard error fall with \(n\), when (2) divides by \(\sqrt{n}\) |
| the slope changes |
misses that the averages in (1) stay the same when every row is copied |