How do ETFs work? Part 2

Tutorial
How ETFs are issued in the United States and in Europe, how a mutual fund can be converted into an ETF, and how ETF flows reach the stocks in an ETF’s basket.
Published

November 9, 2026

At the end of 2025, ETFs in the United States (US) held $13.4 trillion, compared with $23.6 trillion in US mutual funds. US ETFs held 70% of all global ETF assets. During 2025, US ETF assets grew 30%, and mutual fund assets 9%. At this pace, ETFs would surpass mutual funds by the end of 2029.

import matplotlib.pyplot as plt
import pandas as pd

SERIES = {"BOGZ1FL564090005A": "US ETFs", "BOGZ1FL654090000A": "US mutual funds"}
URL = "https://fred.stlouisfed.org/graph/fredgraph.csv?id=" + ",".join(SERIES)

assets = pd.read_csv(URL, index_col=0, parse_dates=True).rename(columns=SERIES)
assets = assets.loc["1993":"2025"] / 1_000_000
assets.index = assets.index.year
print((assets.loc[2025] / assets.loc[2024] - 1).round(3).to_string())

BG, INK, GRID, SPINE = "#FCEFE3", "#1f1f1f", "#EADCCC", "#D5C6B4"
fig, axis = plt.subplots(figsize=(6.4, 4.4))
assets.plot(ax=axis, color=["#0A2540", "#D2822B"], lw=2)
axis.set_xlabel("")
axis.set_ylabel("Trillions of dollars", color=INK)
axis.legend(frameon=False, labelcolor=INK)
fig.patch.set_facecolor(BG)
axis.set_facecolor(BG)
axis.grid(True, axis="y", color=GRID, lw=1.0)
axis.set_axisbelow(True)
axis.spines[["top", "right"]].set_visible(False)
axis.spines[["left", "bottom"]].set_color(SPINE)
axis.tick_params(axis="both", length=0, colors=INK)
fig.savefig("etf_and_mutual_fund_assets.png", dpi=200, bbox_inches="tight")
US ETFs            0.298
US mutual funds    0.090
ETF assets against mutual fund assets US ETFs held $464 million at the end of 1993 and $13.4 trillion at the end of 2025. US mutual funds held $1.5 trillion and $23.6 trillion. The mutual fund figures exclude money market funds. Sources: Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System, series BOGZ1FL564090005A and BOGZ1FL654090000A from FRED.

Assets at the end of 2025

My first post on ETFs gained some attention, so in this post I explain in more detail how ETFs work: how a fund company issues a new ETF or converts a mutual fund into one, and how an ETF’s flows reach the stocks it holds.

Issuing an ETF in the US

A fund company, normally called a sponsor, issues an ETF. The ETF is its own fund, legally separate from the sponsor, and it owns the stocks in its basket. US fund law dates back to 1940 and was written for mutual funds. In a mutual fund, the fund sells shares to any investor and buys them back at the day’s net asset value (NAV), whereas an ETF sells and buys back shares only with dealers. The dealers, called authorized participants, are large banks and trading firms that keep the ETF’s price close to its NAV, as part 1 shows. Investors trade the ETF’s shares directly with each other on the exchange.

Before 2019, there was no specific rule for ETF issuance. So each sponsor needed its own permission from the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC), called an exemptive order, before issuing an ETF.

But in 2019, the SEC adopted a new rule, Rule 6c-11. A sponsor that wants to issue an ETF that meets the rule’s conditions does not need specific SEC permission to issue it.

One main condition is that the ETF’s holdings are transparent: the sponsor posts them on a website every day. One reason for this transparency is that dealers need the holdings to know how much of a discrepancy there is between the ETF’s price and its NAV so that investors can trade the ETF at an efficient price.

Then the sponsor can list the ETF on the exchange, and the dealers sign an agreement under which they can create and redeem its shares.

Issuing an ETF in Europe

Investors in Europe can buy ETFs that are either Undertakings for Collective Investment in Transferable Securities (UCITS) funds or non-UCITS funds. A UCITS fund is a fund set up under the UCITS Directive, a European Union (EU) law for funds that invest money raised from the public. The main difference is that UCITS funds follow stricter rules meant to protect investors.

One protection is a cap on the weight an ETF can have in a company. Under the standard rule, a UCITS ETF can hold at most 10% of its assets in one company, and companies with more than 5% each can together account for at most 40% of its assets. So an ETF can hold at most four companies at 10% each, while the remaining 60% must be in companies weighted at 5% or less. An ETF that is supposed to follow an index can have up to 20% of its assets in one company, and one company can have up to 35% in exceptional market conditions.

Another protection is that an independent depositary holds the ETF’s assets; these assets are kept separate from the sponsor’s own assets, and these assets cannot pay the sponsor’s debts if the sponsor goes bankrupt.

An exchange-traded commodity (ETC) is similar to an ETF. Still, it can track a single commodity, such as gold, silver, or oil, which a UCITS fund cannot do, as a UCITS fund must spread its weights across different commodities. A physically backed gold ETC is a claim on an amount of gold that the sponsor sets before issuing the ETC. The sponsor stores this amount of gold in a vault. Dealers redeem ETCs for gold and can also create new ETCs by handing over more gold. They do this to keep the ETC’s price as close as possible to the value of that gold.

Most European ETFs are UCITS funds. In 2024, ETFs domiciled in Ireland, which are set up under Irish law, held more than 70% of European ETF assets.

One reason sponsors choose Ireland is tax advantages. The US normally withholds 30% of the dividends that US companies pay to foreign investors. But for an ETF domiciled in Ireland, the US usually withholds only 15% under the tax treaty between Ireland and the US. The ETF also pays no Irish tax, so the dividends are not taxed again in Ireland.

The regulator of the country where a UCITS ETF is domiciled must approve it before it is issued, and that approval is valid in every EU country. So an ETF domiciled in Ireland needs the approval of the Central Bank of Ireland.

A UCITS ETF must have “UCITS ETF” in its name. At least one market maker must keep the price close to the NAV. The ETF must also show its holdings. Most ETFs domiciled in Ireland show them every day, but the Central Bank of Ireland allows them to show their holdings as rarely as once a quarter, as long as dealers can still keep the price close to the NAV.

Converting a mutual fund into an ETF

A mutual fund can become an ETF by merging into a new, empty ETF of the same sponsor, as the picture shows. The conversion is designed to be tax-free.

How a mutual fund becomes an ETF An investor owns 100 shares of a mutual fund at a NAV of $20, so the shares are worth $2,000. The sponsor sets up a new, empty ETF with the same goal and the same managers. The mutual fund hands all its stocks to the ETF, and the ETF gives the mutual fund new ETF shares of the same value. The mutual fund passes the ETF shares on to its investors and closes. At $20 a share, the investor gets 100 ETF shares, still worth $2,000. From then on, the investor buys and sells the shares on the exchange, and dealers create and redeem them. The numbers are made up. Investor 100 mutual fund shares, $2,000 Mutual fund Closed New, empty ETF Exchange Investors trade the ETF shares Stocks ETF shares

Sponsors convert mutual funds to lower costs and for the tax advantage explained in part 1. From 2021 through 2025, 191 US mutual funds with $113 billion converted. In Europe, three Luxembourg index funds of Credit Suisse merged into three new Irish UCITS ETFs in March 2020.

Following ETF flows to the stocks

An ETF’s flows are the value of shares created minus the value of shares redeemed. These creations and redemptions are one way heavy buying or selling of an ETF affects the assets it follows. For example, when there is heavy buying in a stock ETF such that the ETF’s price is significantly above the NAV, a dealer buys the stocks in the ETF’s basket and hands them to the ETF in exchange for new ETF shares and sells those shares to those who want to buy the ETF, as part 1 shows. Heavy selling works the other way, as dealers redeem shares with the ETF and sell the stocks. Dealers and other traders can also buy ETF shares and sell the stocks directly, or the reverse, without redeeming or creating ETF shares.

There is no buying or selling of the assets directly that the ETF basket holds when investors trade ETF shares with each other. On average in 2025, trades between investors accounted for 88% of all US ETF activity, and the remaining 12% came from ETF share creations and redemptions. Creations and redemptions of ETFs holding US stocks came to 5.6% of all trading in US company stocks.

Which ETF trades reach the stocks Investors trade ETF shares with each other on the exchange, and no stocks are bought or sold. Heavy buying raises the ETF's price above the NAV. A dealer buys the stocks in the ETF's basket, hands them to the ETF in exchange for new ETF shares, and sells those shares on the exchange. Heavy selling lowers the ETF's price below the NAV. A dealer buys ETF shares on the exchange, hands them to the ETF in exchange for the stocks, and sells the stocks. Exchange Investors trade ETF shares Dealer authorized participant Stock market No stocks traded ETF Holds the stocks Stocks ETF shares

Conclusion

The ETF market is growing and will likely surpass the mutual fund market. To issue an ETF, a sponsor can do so in the US under Rule 6c-11, in Europe once the regulator in the specific country approves it, or by converting a mutual fund into an ETF. ETF investors affect the ETF’s underlying assets through dealers’ creation and redemption of ETF shares.