How do mutual funds, closed-end funds, and hedge funds differ?

Tutorial
Mutual funds, closed-end funds, and hedge funds differ in how investors can trade them, how efficient the trading price is, and how well the rules protect the investors.
Published

November 9, 2026

Updated

November 14, 2026

At the end of 2025, €22.2 trillion was in investment funds in the euro area, excluding money market funds. That money is in different kinds of investment funds, such as mutual funds, closed-end funds and hedge funds, which follow different rules.

My two posts on ETFs explained how an ETF works. In this post, I explain how mutual funds and closed-end funds differ, what hedge funds do, and how the law sorts investment funds in Europe and the US.

Mutual funds and closed-end funds

An investment fund is a pool of money a fund company collects from investors and invests in a basket of assets. Investment funds come in two types, open-end and closed-end. A mutual fund is an open-end investment fund that anyone can buy.

Fund companies have different names in different countries, such as investment advisers in the US and management companies in the European Union. In this post, I call them fund companies.

In a mutual fund, the fund company trades directly with investors by selling new shares to those who want to buy shares in the mutual fund and buying back the shares of those who want to sell. The price the fund company sells or buys shares at is the day’s net asset value (NAV): the value of the mutual fund’s assets minus its debts, per share.

In a listed closed-end fund, the fund company sells a fixed number of shares in an initial public offering. After that, the fund company does not have to buy back shares when investors want to sell, so investors trade shares with one another on the exchange. Because the price is a market price, it can deviate from the NAV. But some closed-end funds are not listed on an exchange, which can delay the investors when they want to buy or sell.

How investors buy and sell shares in a mutual fund and in a closed-end fund In a mutual fund, an investor buys 100 new shares at the NAV of $20 and pays $2,000 to the fund company, which issues the new shares and puts the money into the mutual fund, so the mutual fund now has 1,100 shares. When the investor wants to sell, the fund company buys the 100 shares back at the NAV of $20 and pays $2,000 out of the mutual fund. The fund company cancels the shares, and the mutual fund has 1,000 shares again. A closed-end fund has a fixed 1,000 shares. An investor buys 100 shares from another investor on the exchange at the market price of $18, a discount of $2 to the NAV of $20. The fund company takes no part, and the closed-end fund's shares and assets stay the same. The numbers are made up. Exchange Investor Another investor Mutual fund 1,000 shares, NAV $20 $2,000 100 shares

But unlike an ETF, which is a hybrid of the two, a closed-end fund has no dealer trying to keep the market price close to the NAV. So the market price can deviate from the NAV for a long time.

Investors’ buying and selling of a mutual fund can also force the fund company to buy and sell the assets the mutual fund holds, because the fund company trades directly with investors. In a listed closed-end fund, investors trade with each other, so their trades do not affect the assets the fund holds.

One reason for a closed-end fund is that it can hold illiquid assets, such as private companies, whereas a mutual fund may be forced to sell them when investors sell their shares, which can come at a high trading cost. A closed-end fund can also borrow more than a mutual fund to invest in its basket.

In Europe, every Undertakings for Collective Investment in Transferable Securities (UCITS) fund is open-end, because the UCITS Directive requires the fund company to buy back the shares that investors want to sell. Closed-end funds in Europe are therefore alternative investment funds (AIFs), which I explain in the next section.

UCITS funds and alternative investment funds

In Europe, the law sorts investment funds into two groups. A UCITS fund is set up under the UCITS Directive, the European Union’s law for investment funds sold to the public. All other investment funds are alternative investment funds (AIFs), and the Alternative Investment Fund Managers Directive (AIFMD) sets the rules for AIFs and their fund companies.

Mutual funds, closed-end funds and hedge funds in Europe and in the US An investment fund pools money from many investors. Mutual funds, closed-end funds and hedge funds are three kinds of investment funds. In Europe, the law sorts investment funds into UCITS funds and AIFs. Most money in mutual funds is in UCITS funds, while closed-end funds are AIFs and most hedge fund money is in AIFs. Both UCITS funds and AIFs can be sold to the public, UCITS funds in every country of the European Union and AIFs where a country allows it. In the US, mutual funds and closed-end funds are registered funds that can be sold to the public, while hedge funds are private funds that cannot be offered to the public. Investment funds UCITS funds Sold to the public AIFs To the public where allowed Mutual funds Closed-end funds Hedge funds

The main difference between these two groups is that UCITS funds follow stricter rules meant to protect investors. One protection is a cap on the weight a UCITS fund can have in a company. Under the standard rule, a UCITS fund can hold at most 10% of its assets in one company, and companies with more than 5% each can together account for at most 40% of its assets. So a UCITS fund can hold at most four companies with a weight of 10% each, while the remaining 60% can be held in no company with a weight above 5%. A UCITS fund that is supposed to follow an index can have up to 20% of its assets in one company, and one company can have up to 35% in exceptional market conditions.

Another protection is that an independent depositary holds the UCITS fund’s assets; these assets are kept separate from the fund company’s own assets, and they cannot be used to pay the fund company’s debts if the fund company goes bankrupt.

A UCITS fund must also hold mainly liquid assets, may borrow at most 10% of its assets, and may borrow only for a short time. The fund company must also keep documentation about the UCITS fund’s risks easily available to investors.

An AIF has fewer limits. It can borrow more than 10% of its assets and for longer, and it can hold only a few companies, unlisted companies such as private companies, property, and commodities. An AIF can still let investors buy and sell its shares, but it can choose to do so only on specific occasions, such as once a month. But an AIF normally still needs a depositary, and its fund company must be clear with investors about the AIF’s strategy.

A hedge fund pools money from investors with the goal of a positive return, whatever the market environment. To reach that goal, hedge funds use more flexible strategies than a typical UCITS fund, as they can borrow to place large bets and can also sell short. A hedge fund can use equity strategies, buying stocks expected to rise and selling short those expected to fall, or macro strategies, betting on interest rates, currencies, and commodities. Hedge funds can also use relative value strategies, trading related securities when the prices between them diverge. Or hedge funds can use event-driven strategies, where they trade when mergers, bankruptcies or other corporate events are happening.

The AIFMD was written for funds for professional investors, but each country can allow AIFs to be sold to the public. In Sweden, special funds (specialfonder) are AIFs that can be sold to the public. A special fund that invests in stocks must normally hold at least 8 to 10 companies, depending on the size of these holdings, and investors must be able to sell their shares at least once per year.

In the US, the Investment Company Act of 1940 sorts investment funds into registered funds and private funds. Mutual funds and closed-end funds register with the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) and can be sold to the public. Hedge funds are private funds, which do not have to register because they fall under one of two exclusions in the Act. Section 3(c)(1) excludes funds with at most 100 investors, and section 3(c)(7) excludes funds sold only to qualified purchasers, such as individuals with at least $5 million in investments. A private fund cannot offer its shares to the public.

Most of the money in the euro area’s open-end investment funds is in UCITS funds. At the end of 2025, 60% of the €19.8 trillion in euro-area open-end investment funds was in UCITS funds, and the other 40% in open-end AIFs. All €2.4 trillion in closed-end investment funds was in AIFs. These figures exclude money market funds, which the European Central Bank (ECB) counts separately.

import matplotlib.pyplot as plt
import pandas as pd

URL = (
    "https://data-api.ecb.europa.eu/service/data/IVF/M.U2.N.TA+TB+TC.T00.A.1.Z5.0000.Z01.E"
    "?startPeriod=2025-12&endPeriod=2025-12&format=csvdata"
)
TYPES = {"TA": "open-end", "TB": "closed-end", "TC": "UCITS"}

assets = pd.read_csv(URL).set_index("IVF_REP_SECTOR")["OBS_VALUE"].rename(TYPES) / 1_000_000
bars = pd.DataFrame(
    {
        "UCITS funds": [assets["UCITS"], 0],
        "AIFs": [assets["open-end"] - assets["UCITS"], assets["closed-end"]],
    },
    index=["Open-end investment funds", "Closed-end investment funds"],
)
print(bars.round(1).to_string())
print(f"UCITS funds' share of open-end investment funds: {assets['UCITS'] / assets['open-end']:.0%}")

BG, INK, GRID, SPINE = "#FCEFE3", "#1f1f1f", "#EADCCC", "#D5C6B4"
fig, axis = plt.subplots(figsize=(6.4, 3.2))
bars.plot.barh(ax=axis, stacked=True, color=["#0A2540", "#D2822B"], width=0.5)
axis.invert_yaxis()
axis.set_xlabel("Trillions of euros", color=INK)
axis.legend(frameon=False, labelcolor=INK)
fig.patch.set_facecolor(BG)
axis.set_facecolor(BG)
axis.grid(True, axis="x", color=GRID, lw=1.0)
axis.set_axisbelow(True)
axis.spines[["top", "right"]].set_visible(False)
axis.spines[["left", "bottom"]].set_color(SPINE)
axis.tick_params(axis="both", length=0, colors=INK)
fig.savefig("euro_area_fund_assets.png", dpi=200, bbox_inches="tight")
                             UCITS funds  AIFs
Open-end investment funds           11.9   7.9
Closed-end investment funds          0.0   2.4
UCITS funds' share of open-end investment funds: 60%
Where the money in euro-area investment funds was at the end of 2025 Most of the money in open-end investment funds was in UCITS funds, and all the money in closed-end investment funds was in AIFs. UCITS funds AIFs Open-end investment funds, €19.8 trillion 60%, €11.9 trillion 40%, €7.9 trillion Closed-end investment funds, €2.4 trillion 100% in AIFs

Conclusion

So mutual funds, closed-end funds and hedge funds are all investment funds, pools of money that a fund company collects from a set of investors and invests in a basket of assets. They differ in how investors can trade them, how efficient the trading price is, and how well the rules protect the investors.