There is more to trading than technical analysis
I think there is a misconception among people who want to start trading that technical analysis is the only way. That was also my first thought when I started, around 17 or 18. I am not trading myself today, but I have followed people who trade, and I have listened to many interviews with profitable traders, in books such as Jack Schwager’s Market Wizards and in podcasts such as Talking with Traders and the Swedish Fill or Kill and Börsens Finest. A pattern is that technical analysis is not the only way, and that there are other things besides technical analysis when it comes to trading.
The trigger
When I listen to many of these traders, the trigger comes up again and again. You can have an idea, a pitch, or an intuition that something should happen, then wait for the trigger that confirms it, like a sniper or a lion waiting for prey. Take a defense stock like Saab, whose share price was weak for years because many countries cut their defense budgets. Then came Russia’s invasion of Ukraine in February 2022, and suddenly you had the trigger that you had been waiting for so long. Cheap defense stocks should no longer be cheap, because states would now finance their armies and have large budgets. Sure, this example is hindsight, but it shows how at least some of the people I listen to are thinking.
What it means for someone starting out
I think someone starting needs to see what fits them. Even within technical analysis, many different setups can be profitable. Maybe someone has a natural talent for understanding and processing news and taking bets on different triggers. Or maybe they like to be more systematic and define a set of factors that they can trade on.
I am not a trader myself. I am more of an investor, and I use a set of factor investing setups.
Limitations
The people I listen to are the ones who have succeeded, and that is the limitation of my view. There might be other traders who have not succeeded and who trade in the same way as these successful traders. At the same time, these traders have also talked about when it has not worked, and why, so it cuts both ways.
Conclusion
So my conclusion is, do not limit yourself to thinking that technical analysis is the only way in trading. Instead, choose what fits your personality, and remember that proper risk management and a solid setup, together, lead to profitable trading over the long term.
Read next
- How to do factor investing How to turn value and momentum into one score, select and weight 100 stocks, and rebalance them with trading costs, on simulated data.
- The Magic Formula worked. Just not lately. Greenblatt’s Magic Formula returned 11.1% a year after trading costs, against 8.7% for the S&P 500 from 2001 to 2026, and has trailed it since about 2015.
- Which part of shareholder yield pays? From 2001 to 2026, the 30 large US stocks with the highest dividend yield beat the S&P 500 by 1.7 points a year after trading costs.
Disclaimer: for discussion purposes only. Not investment advice. The share prices in the picture are made up.